I had to get on tape the exact test I rode just a few days ago that I received a whopping score of 53 on. The vast difference of the horse under me today and the horse under me on Saturday would make you think they were two different horses. Really if you were blindfolded and riding I don't think you would ever guess they were the same horse.
So you be the judge. Literally what score would you give on this test? Besides the cranky canter transitions his movement was quite nice. And that free walk, hello coefficients! The hip dislocating swinging hindend and over reaching, stretching over his back..sigh.
I guess one good way to look at it is that in the end my dressage score didn't even matter because I fell on my head! Now if only one of these days I can get THIS horse to show up at a horse show. The same horse that I get every day at home now that would be awesome!